10 Cheapest Housing Markets

10 Cheapest Housing Markets
September 12, 2016 Marketing GrafWebCUSO

The cost of housing has to be a major consideration for retirees looking to make their savings last, considering that it eats up such a large share of annual income.

Experts recommend that people spend no more than 30% of their income on housing, but the cost of a place to live has risen steadily despite the fact that salaries haven’t — and the 30% recommendation has been around for years.

In fact, the less a household’s median annual income, the larger a percentage of it they’ll be spending on housing, with a Pew Charitable Trusts report earlier this year finding that households with annual incomes in the lower third spent 40% of their income on housing in 2014. Renters in that third spent even more — nearly half of what they made.

With housing prices having escalated to the point where the median price of a home in a U.S. metro area is now above the $1 million mark — so says 24/7 Wall St. — what they’ll end up paying for a place to live has to be factored into anyone’s retirement plans, no matter where they live. After all, that’s when they’re planning on getting by on less income than during their working years, and will have less flexibility in income to make up for any blips.

In January, Kiplinger forecasted that home prices would moderate during 2016 because of tight supply, and Bankrate.com has pointed out that fall can be a good time to buy a house because of slowing home-buying activity. That said, however, Trulia reported near the end of July that homebuilding is weak and prices are rising. That tighter supply could mean that would-be buyers could once again see bidding wars in really tight markets.

While housing availability is more elastic in some markets than others, where to buy depends on a great many factors in addition to price. Would-be retirees keeping an eye on the final cost also have to consider the many other aspects of retirement living in any given area. Still, when trying to stretch those retirement dollars as far as possible, dropping too many of them on a new home would be a mistake.

To determine the most and least expensive housing markets, 24/7 Wall St. reviewed median single-family home prices from the National Association of Realtors. Salaries within a region play a large part in determining housing prices, since housing prices tend to correlate with an area’s median household income.

And while nationwide, the median household income is more than enough to qualify for a mortgage to purchase a typical home, that doesn’t hold true for the most expensive housing markets — where would-be buyers could need multiples of their salary just to get their feet over the threshold. In fact, homeownership rates actually come in higher than the national rate in 24 of the 25 cheapest markets. The opposite is true in expensive markets, with the homeownership rates lower than the national rate in the majority of areas.

To identify the most and least expensive housing markets, 24/7 Wall St. reviewed median single-family home prices in the second quarter of 2016 as released by the National Association of Realtors. Qualifying incomes assuming a 20% down payment for metro areas are also from the NAR for the same time period. Median household incomes and homeownership rates are from the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2014 American Community Survey. 24/7 Wall St. then calculated monthly mortgage payments using a 3.9% interest rate and assuming a 20% down payment — the same measures used by the NAR to compare housing affordability at the metro area level.

With all that in mind, here’s 24/7 Wall St.’s 10 cheapest housing markets.

top 10 cheapest housing marketsThe University of Notre Dame is located in South Bend, Ind., and is home to the Fighting Irish football team that has brought home 16 national championships.

10. South Bend-Mishawaka, Indiana-Michigan


2016 Q2 median sale price: $121,800.

Qualifying income with 20% down: $22,267.

Median household income: $46,610.

Monthly payment: $460.

top 10 cheapest housing marketsPeoria, about three hours southwest of Chicago, is home to Caterpillar Inc., the city’s top employer with over 15,000 employees.

9. Peoria, Illinois


2016 Q2 median sale price: $120,500.

Qualifying income with 20% down: $22,029.

Median household income: $56,186.

Monthly payment: $455.

top 10 cheapest housing marketsElmira might not be one of New York’s most notable cities, but familiar names such as Tommy Hilfiger and Brian Williams are from the town situated near the Pennsylvania border.

8. Elmira, New York


2016 Q2 median sale price: $115,600.

Qualifying income with 20% down: $21,134.

Median household income: $50,232.

Monthly payment: $436.

top 10 cheapest housing marketsNear the lake that bears the same name, Erie, Pa., is known as the “Flagship City” because it’s the home port of Oliver Hazard Perry’s Niagara.

7. Erie, Pennsylvania


2016 Q2 median sale price: $115,100.

Qualifying income with 20% down: $21,042.

Median household income: $45,560.

Monthly payment: $434.

top 10 cheapest housing marketsAn 1886 flood destroyed the original Wichita River falls for which the city was name. The city built an artificial waterfall near the river in Lucy Park for visitors.

6. Wichita Falls, Texas


2016 Q2 median sale price: $109,800.

Qualifying income with 20% down: $20,073.

Median household income: $43,804.

Monthly payment: $414.

top 10 cheapest housing marketsThe city touts itself as a big city in terms of size, but in terms of low-cost living and activities, it considers itself a small town.

5. Rockford, Illinois


2016 Q2 median sale price: $109,000.

Qualifying income with 20% down: $19,927.

Median household income: $48,385.

Monthly payment: $411.

top 10 cheapest housing marketsIBM was founded near Binghamton, and since its days of cigar, shoes and computer production, the city is become well-known for health care and education.

4. Binghamton, New York


2016 Q2 median sale price: $105,500.

Qualifying income with 20% down: $19,287.

Median household income: $48,188.

Monthly payment: $398.

top 10 cheapest housing marketsDecatur, Ill., was originally the hometown of the Chicago Bears, but only between 1919 and 1920.

3. Decatur, Illinois


2016 Q2 median sale price: $95,600.

Qualifying income with 20% down: $17,477.

Median household income: $47,574.

Monthly payment: $361.

top 10 cheapest housing marketsOnly 150 miles away from Washington, Cumberland, Md., has a rich history of its own. The city served as an outpost for then-Col. George Washington during the French and Indian War, and was his first military headquarters.

2. Cumberland, Maryland-West Virginia

2016 Q2 median sale price: $94,900.

Qualifying income with 20% down: $17,349.

Median household income: $38,580.

Monthly payment: $358.

top 10 cheapest housing marketsYoungstown, Ohio is only 10 miles west of the Pennsylvania border, halfway between New York City and Chicago.

1. Youngstown-Warren-Boardman, Ohio-Pennsylvania

2016 Q2 median sale price: $85,400.

Qualifying income with 20% down: $15,612.

Median household income: $42,228.

Monthly payment: $322.

Originally published on BenefitsPro. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.